"I am a national correspondent with Newhouse Newspapers, based in D.C." began Jonathan Tilove's self-introduction to us. Interested in "analyzing" some of our critical studies, Mr. Tilove posted a number of "investigative" questions as these two below:

• Who is the "I" in isurvived?
  
  
• From this site and your others it appears that you enjoy no holds-barred controversy.
  But doesn't simple decency suggest certain limits?
  

Some two months after he contacted us with his "probative" questions, Jonathan Tilove published an article attacking some of our Holocaust critical studies on unspecified grounds, apparently just for sports. To see the rest of all this, and our reply to Jonathan Tilove's article, please click on the button below.